Innkeeper's Lodge Edinburgh South Queensferry

Good
Traveller Type: young couple
  : Quaint and historical hotel. Decent bar and restaurant with friendly helpful staff.
  : Check in at 3 is getting on a bit and there seem to be no flexibility with this .Staff tried hard but felt like they were expected to do so much especially in the restaurant. Needed some experienced management on hand to organise better.Very noisy location with a busy port nearby including pipes blasting out ! At night the local bikers seemed to use the road in front as a racetrack reving their engines all night.

Wonderful
Traveller Type: young couple
  : very nice and warm welcome. Good tips for regional trips received

Good
Traveller Type: young couple
  : Nice character filled property
  : Accessibility is not good at all- only stairs

Wonderful
Traveller Type: family with young children

Very Good
Traveller Type: family with young children
  : Excellent cleanliness. Nice and welcoming staff. Good dinner and breakfast. Free parking on site.
  : Bad insulation of the room, which was located in the basement.

Very Good
Traveller Type: solo traveller

Very Poor
Traveller Type: family with young children
  : Do not recommend anyone to choose this hotel, we have been traveling a lot, but here, definately, client is not of interest of their services

Good
Traveller Type: young couple
  : Great location & cute property.
  : Our toilet had problems & even staying 1 night made the stay a little problematic. Enjoyed our meal in the restaurant but the dining side seemed under staffed

Very Good
Traveller Type: young couple
  : Nifty old (really old, like Robert Louis Stevenson stayed there and wrote about it in Kidnapped, old) tavern right across from the ferry and just about smack below the train bridge. Room (#3) we had was tucked in a basement and not damp but plenty dark with a single window out to the rear. Tavern dinner was an unexpected treat with a hoisin duck pizza and local lamb skewer. Server was a delight with local insights (we always ask what "not to do" as to get a better feel of a place away from other tourists and she clued us in very well). She really made the experience a joy.When we asked what would be a good sweet to cap off the meal, she suggested and delivered. Not being familiar with this crazy dessert, Pavlova, with mango and white chocolate wafers, the presentation was a surprise. Perfect balance of tart, crunch, sweet and though the size was deceptive it was perfect for two. The méringue just melts on the tongue. All within a few feet of a cornerstone etched 1683.
  : A little odd needing to access our room past the kitchen service door and around the back. Parking lot not unpleasant but, a parking lot still. When I asked in the morning for some "real coffee" since the room had only instant, someone at the tavern bar told me there was nothing to be found in the area before 9am. Ventured out and brought back lattes and pastries from about a mile and a half. If we hadn't been on a schedule we would have stayed for breakfast once they opened.

Wonderful
Traveller Type: young couple
  : Historic inn located literally under Forth railway bridge. Rooms were spacious with separate lounge and modern bathroom. Good restaurant, although a little pricey. Only 600 metres to Railway station to Edinburgh.
  : Train noise, but given location what do you expect.